Nominations Clarification

[tentaclemod]

Okay, so a few titles that have been nominated are a bit unclear, mainly due to me being an eldritch creature but not an all-knowing one.

• Star Wars. It has been nominated under a few disambiguations. Mainly, I'm puzzled by the archive-only derivatives, because why make a difference for an exchange based mainly on osmosis -- which has much of the same canon. (This is for the nominations Star Wars Original Trilogy, Star Wars Prequel Trilogy, and Star Wars Sequel Trilogy) I'd be much more comfortable including, say, The Force Awakens on its own, but feel free to convince me otherwise.
• Figure Skating RPF. If the nominator would please explain to me how that could be misapprehended, I'd be happy to approve it, but this is a thing that exists in real life and I'm leery of approving it without any details at all.
• Same with Hockey RPF which already has been approved.

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

So we should remove the disambiguations like (TV) or years when we nom? I just figured we should use archive tags and just ignore those bits.

[tentaclemod]

Yes, ignoring the bits makes sense! Which is why I'm inclined to change those nominations into a single one, Star Wars - All Media Types, because the separate tags wouldn't make sense.

[theladywanderer]

Hi, I'm Casylum on the archive, and I put in for Hockey RPF because it seemed like the best way to nominate hockey in general, as a sport/culture/fandom. It's less a "I don't understand/know anything about the shipping of these real athletes" and more "I don't understand/know anything about the sport at all, please tell me how you think it's played/what the fan culture surrounding it is".

[tentaclemod]

That makes so much more sense than what I thought it meant! :D thank you, I will keep it <3